The Prescription for Painful Joints? When to Move, When to Rest
4 min. read
Baptist Health Orthopedic Care
When your knee aches, your hip feels stiff or your hands hurt, the natural response may be to give the troublesome joint a break. Sometimes rest is exactly what an injury needs.
But when arthritis is causing the discomfort, becoming less active can actually work against you, experts with Baptist Health Orthopedic Care say. And that’s the message they want to share for World Arthritis Day, observed Oct. 12.
Arthritis affects an estimated 53.2 million U.S. adults—roughly one in five—and nearly 44 percent of adults with arthritis say it limits their everyday activities, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).
For many people with arthritis, however, appropriate exercise isn’t something to avoid. It’s an important part of managing the condition.
According to Harris Gellman, M.D., an orthopedic hand surgeon with Baptist Health Orthopedic Care, arthritis pain tends to develop more gradually than pain from an acute injury, and may involve persistent aching and stiffness.
“Determining what is actually causing the pain is an important first step,” says Dr. Gellman, who specializes in the treatment of elbow, wrist and hand conditions including arthritis, Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, fractures and other conditions.
Why Movement Can Help
Arthritis is an umbrella term for conditions affecting the joints. Osteoarthritis, its most common form, involves changes in cartilage and other tissues within the joint, while inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis involve the immune system.
Either way, Dr. Gellman says, pain often creates a cycle: A joint hurts, so you use it less. Less activity can lead to weaker muscles and greater stiffness, making movement more difficult and potentially encouraging even more inactivity.
Regular physical activity can help interrupt that cycle. The CDC says exercise can reduce arthritis-related joint pain while improving function and mood. It can also strengthen the muscles that support joints and help people maintain mobility.
That doesn’t mean exercising through significant pain or ignoring what your body is telling you, however.
When evaluating persistent joint symptoms, “the physical exam is critical,” Dr. Gellman says. Physicians look at such things as range of motion, stability and tenderness to determine whether arthritis, an injury or another condition may be responsible.
Annie Plate, M.D., an orthopedic hand surgeon with Baptist Health Orthopedic Care who specializes in arthritis and other hand and upper-extremity conditions, sees every day how different conditions can affect function. She emphasizes the importance of tailoring care to the individual.
“That means discussing the patient’s expectations and goals and developing a treatment plan aimed at returning them to the activities that matter most to them.” Dr. Plate says.
What Kind of Exercise Is Best?
There is no single arthritis workout for everyone. The goal is movement that challenges the body without unnecessarily aggravating the affected joint.
The CDC recommends joint-friendly activities such as:
• Walking
• Cycling
• Swimming or water exercise
• Light gardening
• Dancing
• Tai chi
• Strength exercises using appropriate weights or resistance bands
Range-of-motion and flexibility exercises also can help keep joints moving, while strengthening the muscles around a painful joint can provide additional support. Water exercise can be particularly useful for people with painful hips or knees because buoyancy reduces the load on weight-bearing joints.
For adults who are able, federal guidelines call for at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity each week, plus muscle-strengthening exercise on at least two days.
That doesn’t have to happen in long workouts, Dr. Plate notes.
“Five- or 10-minute sessions can be beneficial and can be easier for someone just starting out,” she says.
The Arthritis Foundation advises starting slowly and increasing activity gradually rather than dramatically increasing duration, resistance or intensity all at once.
For arthritis affecting the hands and wrists, Dr. Plate says the same principle of maintaining useful movement applies, although the specific exercises and modifications may differ.
Know When Pain Is Telling You to Stop
Some mild soreness or stiffness can occur when beginning a new activity, particularly if you haven’t exercised regularly, says Dr. Gellman.
“Temporary discomfort after starting a physical activity program can be normal and should improve as the body adjusts,” he assures.
You also shouldn’t automatically assume persistent joint pain is arthritis, he says.
An injury often has a more identifiable starting point—a fall, twist or other event—while arthritis symptoms often develop over time. Swelling, redness, warmth, numbness, tingling, weakness or pain that significantly limits everyday activities are additional reasons to seek an evaluation.
“Severe pain that doesn’t improve or keeps coming back warrants medical attention,” Dr. Gellman says. “An accurate diagnosis allows treatment and activity recommendations to be tailored to the underlying problem.”
The broader message for people living with arthritis is not that they should push through every painful joint. It is that pain doesn’t necessarily mean movement is harmful.
With the right type and amount of activity—and guidance from a physician or physical therapist when needed—staying active can be one of the most useful tools for keeping joints functioning and preserving the ability to do the things you enjoy.
Click here for more information about the services and specialists available at Baptist Health Orthopedic Care.
Featured Providers
Harris Gellman, MD
Harris Gellman, M.D., FACS, is a board-certified, fellowship-trained orthopedic hand surgeon at Baptist Health Orthopedic Care. He specializes in the treatment of a multitude of elbow, wrist and hand conditions, including arthritis, Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, fracture, ligament and tendon injuries, trauma and neuromuscular disorders. He also treats upper extremity paralysis caused by brachial plexus injury, cerebral palsy, stroke and spinal cord injuries.
Dr. Gellman performs such procedures as arthroscopy, platelet-rich plasma injections, microvascular surgery, minimally invasive surgery, reconstructive surgery as well as tendon repair, reconstruction and transfers.
Committed to the mentoring, teaching and training of medical students, residents and fellows, Dr. Gellman has held several educational leadership positions throughout his career. He currently serves as a clinical professor of orthopedic surgery at Nova Southeastern University College of Osteopathic Medicine in Davie, Florida.
Dr. Gellman earned his medical degree at the Lewis Katz School of Medicine at Temple University in Philadelphia. He completed an orthopedic surgery residency at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. He also completed a hand and microvascular surgery fellowship at the University of California in San Diego and an orthopedic surgery fellowship at the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. He is certified by the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery and has also earned Subspecialty Certification in Surgery of the Hand.
Dr. Gellman is a fellow of the American College of Surgeons and a member of several professional organizations. He is an editorial reviewer for several high-impact medical journals. He is actively involved in clinical research and publishes his results in peer-reviewed scientific journals and presents his work and national and international symposiums.
To provide patient-centered care, Dr. Gellman spends time with his patients and listens intently to their medical history and symptoms. He finds that this open communication helps him make a diagnosis, especially for patients who have seen multiple doctors who have not successfully identified the problem and offered a treatment plan.
During his free time, Dr. Gellman enjoys spending time with his family and reading.
Annie Catherine Plate, MD
Annie Plate, M.D. (formerly Annie Weber, M.D.), is a board certified orthopedic hand surgeon, specializing in fracture management, arthritis, nerve compression, joint replacement and microsurgery, at Baptist Health.Prior to joining Baptist Health in 2022, Dr. Plate completed her hand and upper extremity fellowship at Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center. During her residency, she received the University of Maryland Resident Researcher of the Year award and an AOTrauma North America’s 2019 Resident Research grant. She is a member of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons and the American Society for Surgery of the Hand. A strong believer in giving back to the community, Dr. Plate served as a mentor for the University of Maryland School of Medicine Orthopaedic Interest Group, a counselor at Camp Open Arms and a member of the University of Maryland Medical Center Orthopaedics Resident Education Improvement Committee. Dr. Plate believes in building trusting, open and informative patient-physician relationships. With evidence-based, understandable healthcare plans, she provides the best treatment option to meet individual goals.When she is not treating patients, Dr. Plate enjoys activities on the water – sailing, snorkeling and SCUBA diving.
Trusted Orthopedic Care to Keep You Moving
Related Stories
View All Articles
Antibiotics Save Lives. But What Happens When They Stop Working?
November 16, 2026
5 min. read
Gloria Drummond Patient Tower Opens at Boca Raton Regional Hospital
November 9, 2026
2 min. read
Video
Turkey Trot Tips: Getting to the Finish Line Without Getting Hurt
November 3, 2026
4 min. read